From: Veter Kamenev <nilfs19@inetstar.ru>
To: linux-nilfs@vger.kernel.org
Subject: I'm trying NILFS2 in kernels 6.6.12, 6.7.12, 6.8.4
Date: Fri, 19 Apr 2024 19:02:57 +0300 [thread overview]
Message-ID: <bbac8195-cf8d-1685-9038-9d45cb9865d7@inetstar.ru> (raw)
Hi folks!
I learned about Nilfs2 many years ago and was impressed by its capabilities. The idea is brilliant!
But due to glitches, I returned back to reiserfs3, which works like a charm, although it will be removed from the kernel in 2025.
Now, after several years, I decided to return to Nilfs2, hoping that the bugs have been corrected.
To my greatest regret, I received errors in all kernels and the system went into read-only state.
Luckily I didn't lose any data.
The texts of the errors will be below in the letter. In this regard, I have 2 questions:
1. What is the reason that after so many years, Nilfs2 still cannot work stably?
2. Are the errors I sent corrected? If fixed, then starting with what version of the kernel?
Bugs:
Apr 14 15:10:10 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty page: offset=2579136512, ino=3
Apr 14 15:10:10 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty block: blocknr=0, size=4096
Apr 14 15:10:10 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty page: offset=4329472, ino=6
Apr 14 15:10:10 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty block: blocknr=81375872, size=4096
Apr 14 15:10:10 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty page: offset=5189632, ino=1593910
Apr 14 15:10:10 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty block: blocknr=0, size=4096
Apr 14 15:10:10 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty page: offset=45056, ino=33745
Apr 14 15:10:10 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty block: blocknr=81477095, size=4096
Apr 14 15:10:10 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty page: offset=0, ino=1594060
Apr 14 15:10:10 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty block: blocknr=0, size=4096
Apr 14 15:10:10 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty page: offset=2580111360, ino=3
Apr 14 15:10:10 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty block: blocknr=0, size=4096
Apr 14 15:10:10 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty page: offset=6815744, ino=6
Apr 14 15:10:10 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty block: blocknr=81370706, size=4096
Apr 14 15:10:10 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty page: offset=2580316160, ino=3
Apr 14 15:10:10 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty block: blocknr=0, size=4096
Apr 14 15:10:10 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty page: offset=7106560, ino=6
Apr 14 15:10:10 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty block: blocknr=5320006, size=4096
Apr 14 15:10:15 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty page: offset=7139328, ino=6
Apr 14 15:10:15 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty block: blocknr=5320014, size=4096
Apr 14 15:10:15 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty page: offset=45056, ino=33745
Apr 14 15:10:15 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty block: blocknr=81477095, size=4096
Apr 14 15:10:15 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty page: offset=7282688, ino=6
Apr 14 15:10:15 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty block: blocknr=80559629, size=4096
Apr 14 15:10:20 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty page: offset=2580275200, ino=3
Apr 14 15:10:20 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty block: blocknr=0, size=4096
Apr 14 15:10:20 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty page: offset=12890112, ino=6
Apr 14 15:10:20 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty block: blocknr=81369152, size=4096
Apr 14 15:10:20 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty page: offset=0, ino=54311
Apr 14 15:10:20 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty block: blocknr=0, size=4096
Apr 14 15:10:20 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty page: offset=5189632, ino=1593910
Apr 14 15:10:20 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty block: blocknr=81477110, size=4096
Apr 14 15:10:20 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty page: offset=45056, ino=33745
Apr 14 15:10:20 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty block: blocknr=81477095, size=4096
Apr 14 15:10:20 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty page: offset=20029440, ino=6
Apr 14 15:10:20 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty block: blocknr=81370709, size=4096
--
Apr 14 15:10:24 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): nilfs_get_block (ino=55694): a race condition while inserting a data block at offset=0
Apr 14 15:10:24 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): nilfs_get_block (ino=55694): a race condition while inserting a data block at offset=0
Apr 14 15:10:24 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): nilfs_get_block (ino=55694): a race condition while inserting a data block at offset=0
Apr 14 15:10:25 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty page: offset=20369408, ino=6
Apr 14 15:10:25 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty block: blocknr=81375846, size=4096
Apr 14 15:10:25 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty page: offset=45056, ino=33745
Apr 14 15:10:25 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty block: blocknr=81477095, size=4096
Apr 14 15:10:25 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty page: offset=0, ino=55694
Apr 14 15:10:25 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty block: blocknr=0, size=4096
Apr 14 15:10:25 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty page: offset=22556672, ino=6
Apr 14 15:10:25 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty block: blocknr=81370389, size=4096
--
Apr 14 15:10:30 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty page: offset=84746240, ino=6
Apr 14 15:10:30 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty block: blocknr=58879578, size=4096
Apr 14 15:10:30 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty page: offset=45056, ino=33745
Apr 14 15:10:30 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty block: blocknr=81477095, size=4096
Apr 14 15:10:30 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty page: offset=201527296, ino=6
Apr 14 15:10:30 MainPC kernel: NILFS (dm-5): discard dirty block: blocknr=81375118, size=4096
Sincerely yours,
Veter Kamenev
next reply other threads:[~2024-04-19 16:08 UTC|newest]
Thread overview: 2+ messages / expand[flat|nested] mbox.gz Atom feed top
2024-04-19 16:02 Veter Kamenev [this message]
2024-04-19 17:41 ` I'm trying NILFS2 in kernels 6.6.12, 6.7.12, 6.8.4 Ryusuke Konishi
Reply instructions:
You may reply publicly to this message via plain-text email
using any one of the following methods:
* Save the following mbox file, import it into your mail client,
and reply-to-all from there: mbox
Avoid top-posting and favor interleaved quoting:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Posting_style#Interleaved_style
* Reply using the --to, --cc, and --in-reply-to
switches of git-send-email(1):
git send-email \
--in-reply-to=bbac8195-cf8d-1685-9038-9d45cb9865d7@inetstar.ru \
--to=nilfs19@inetstar.ru \
--cc=linux-nilfs@vger.kernel.org \
/path/to/YOUR_REPLY
https://kernel.org/pub/software/scm/git/docs/git-send-email.html
* If your mail client supports setting the In-Reply-To header
via mailto: links, try the mailto: link
Be sure your reply has a Subject: header at the top and a blank line
before the message body.
This is a public inbox, see mirroring instructions
for how to clone and mirror all data and code used for this inbox;
as well as URLs for read-only IMAP folder(s) and NNTP newsgroup(s).